case study
Bitter Harvest: A Case of Merit, Trust, and Succession
One Successor Wasn’t Ready. A Clearer Leadership Structure Was. How LeadFBE™ helped a ₹600 crore agri-export family business move from an unspoken succession contest to defined roles, independent financial oversight and a two-year leadership trial.

A growing business. An unwritten succession plan.
FT Agro Exports Pvt. Ltd. - name changed for confidentiality - was founded in 1989 by Mahadevan Deshmukh.
With headquarters in Ahmedabad and a factory in Nashik, the grape-export business grew to ₹600 crore in revenue in FY 2023–24, serving Europe, the Middle East and Southeast Asia.
Its next leadership chapter was less clearly defined.
Mahadevan’s elder daughter, Ritika, worked closely with farmers and sourcing networks. Her husband, Karan, joined the business in 2014 with an implicit expectation that he would eventually take over operations.
But an expectation is not an agreement.
There was no explicit succession discussion, no shared definition of readiness and no clear pathway through which Karan could earn greater authority.
Recognition became entangled with control.
Karan worked hard, but continued to experience the company as his wife’s family business.
“I don’t need control. I just need to be taken seriously.”
Seeking to demonstrate capability, he began making independent decisions on vendor contracts and machinery purchases. Some resulted in cost overruns and reputational concerns.
For Karan, independent action represented an opportunity to prove himself.
For Mahadevan, it raised concerns about judgment and accountability.
“Why is he in a hurry to control what I built with blood and sweat?”
Each interpreted the other’s behaviour through a different emotional lens. Karan experienced scrutiny as exclusion. Mahadevan experienced unilateral decisions as a threat to stewardship.
Ritika became caught between her husband and father and withdrew emotionally.
The business had growing leadership needs, but no shared agreement on who could decide what.
The peacemaker became a potential successor.
In 2021, the younger daughter, Isha, returned from New York to help resolve the tensions.
She built rapport, facilitated conversations and proposed practical improvements: documented procedures, digitisation and team performance reviews.
Her involvement initially offered common ground.
Then Mahadevan began to see her as someone who could lead the business and encouraged her to stay.
Her position changed. The person who had entered as a bridge was now also a potential successor.
A peacemaker’s role becomes harder when the outcome may favour them.
The family engaged LeadFBE™ to facilitate realignment and support a more structured succession decision.
Making emotional ownership visible
LeadFBE’s Emotional Ownership Mapping™ surfaced the concerns beneath the disagreements:
Karan: “I just want to be seen as capable - not tolerated.” Mahadevan: “He’s trying to take what I haven’t finished giving.” Isha: “We are losing business because no one’s steering from clarity.” Ritika: “I just want peace in the family and the business.”
These accounts helped distinguish the need for recognition, the responsibility of stewardship, the demand for operational clarity and the desire for family stability.
They were connected concerns, but they required different responses.
Assessing readiness beyond family position
LeadFBE™ assessed the three next-generation members across strategic vision, financial acumen, stakeholder trust, conflict management and emotional readiness.
The process combined psychometric tools, employee focus groups and stakeholder engagement.
Family member - Case-specific Merit Index Karan 54/100 Ritika 42/100 Isha 68/100
The assessment indicated that none was ready for an immediate, unsupported leadership transition. Financial acumen and emotional readiness emerged as significant development needs.
Isha’s higher score informed the proposed structure; it did not remove the need for development or oversight.
Succession readiness is a development question , not a measure of someone’s value to the family.
Giving each role a clearer mandate
The intervention moved the family towards a two-year role trial.
Isha would lead the traditional business, supported by an experienced executive while developing her financial and export-market capability.
Karan would lead a separate pomegranate-kernel venture, with support from Mahadevan and Ritika. This created a defined entrepreneurial mandate with a clearer basis for accountability.
Ritika would oversee sourcing, farm contracts and grower relationships across both businesses, building on her existing strengths.
The structure reduced the need to force all three into a single leadership hierarchy. Its effectiveness would still depend on clear budgets, decision rights and arrangements between the businesses.
Making governance practical
An external CFO was appointed after financial understanding emerged as a shared gap.
Monthly financial reports, dashboards and governance meetings were introduced to create a common basis for reviewing performance.
A family constitution and a phased founder exit plan were also drafted.
Together, these measures aimed to make authority more explicit, performance more visible and the founder’s transition more deliberate.
The LeadFBE™ perspective
Succession becomes difficult when one appointment is expected to resolve every emotional and business need.
Recognition, ownership, employment and executive authority need explicit agreements of their own.
In this case, differentiated roles created a pathway for testing leadership while preserving opportunities for contribution.
A family can share a legacy without sharing the same job description.
